The Silence of Deafness is an Abstract, not an Absolute.
So I was reading Salon.com, and it occurred to me that there hasn’t really been much discussion here about the protests going on right now- or (at least recently) much about Deaf cultural identity (click on the link fora better idea of what I’m referring to).
What do you all think about the uproar over this woman’s qualifications toward being “deaf-enough”?
On some feminist blogs recently, there was a huge debate over whether a woman could be feminine and engage in girly beauty rituals and still call herself a feminist. The Gallaudet debate feels kind of similar.
What are some other social networks/cultures similar to being Deaf? That is to say- are there other minority cultures where the majority/outsiders perceive members as being debilitated/weakened while the members themselves perceive themselves as simply having an identity that is unique to the majority?
Thoughts?
For those into clever mockumentaries about people with hearing loss and into the DJ/dance club scene…go check out “It’s All Gone, Pete Tong”….it’s brilliant shyte.
Google it! Rent the DVD…I saw it at some deaf film festival here for the first time. If you liked “Trainspotting”, it’s like that in style…
oi!
EDIT: by the way, it’s about one superstar DJ who’s got a hearing loss and deals with it…it’s quite a good movie. Trust me.
…you were either completely deaf, or completely hearing? the majority of us here (I think) have some bit of hearing, and quiet frankly I for one, am tired!
Maybe im having a bad day of it, I dunno, but I wish so hard that I was either one way or the other with deafness, this ‘in between’ stage hurts!
The majority of people I meet dont ever know I have a hearing problem, and thats great, but I DO!! and its so hard to always have to concentrate, to lipread to get on day to day and sometimes I feel people that do know my deafness look at me and think theres nothing wrong with her! I have fine speach, I am not in the habit of saying ‘what’ I dont have a sign language interp, because im not skilled enough, The only thing is I wear 2 aids, but thats it, I look, sound, act and seem fine, BUT IM NOT! I get pissed off!! I laugh when other people laugh, because its whats expected of me, but nearly always I miss the punchline!
more often than not I get on fine, and I feel fine,Im a generally very happy go lucky girl, but then I get days like this and I feel lost, I dont know …just one of those days, I feel like iv missed the punchline!
*sorry for the venting!
I am curious to know how you cope with watching TV. I personally find it to be a real strain. Here in South Africa they dont really cater for the deaf/hearing impaired. We have a 5 minute news at 6 in the evenings which has someone signing and on a Saturday afternoon they have a show with subtitles and signing specifically for the deaf and thats it. None of the other shows have subtitles or signing which I feel is very wrong.
Life is about the constant realization and re-realization of subtle things, or things that we’ve lived with for so long that we barely even notice them anymore.
On Friday I went to a recital where a classical concert pianist performed, and was startled by a sudden clear juxtaposition of two sounds: The soundtrack of the performance, and the soundtrack of the voice of the man that introduced the pianist.
The English language, and the language of music.
His voice was by no means harsh. It was low-pitched and most likely very pleasant. But because my ears cannot make words out of the collection of sounds, all I heard was that it was out of tune. Erratic. The agitated warbling of a sparrow whose nest has been disturbed. It hadn’t even the peaceful quality of white noise, which is hypnotic in it’s repetition. The pauses and emphasis, the differing sounds of consonants and vowels, sibilants and plosives- they acted together to create almost an anti-music. Jarring, uncomfortable, I felt a headache growing inside my skull as if I were listening to the amplified sounds of a demolition team tearing down a high-rise just a few feet away.
And then, silence.
And from the silence, the music welled. I don’t know if your perceptions of music/song and the spoken word mirror mine, or if they’re different- and the juxtaposition less jarring. But for me, music is something different from sound altogether. It sweeps one’s senses clean, no matter how little of it I can hear- it retains it’s melody and it’s purpose even as my ears drop out certain frequencies and break up the song.
And I realized, more clearly than ever before- that without meaning, the human voice is simply an instrument to my ears. When in song, it follows the rules of music. When speaking, it’s an instrument played badly and out of tune.
It’s that simple.
[powered by WordPress.]

SomewhatSilent is an international community blogging effort centered around d/Deafness, hard of hearing, etc.
All are welcome.
* Politeness is an implied requirement. The community reserves it's right to banish trolls and jerks.
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| « Sep | Nov » | |||||
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
| 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
| 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
| 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
| 30 | 31 | |||||
853 queries. 2.038 seconds [powered by WordPress.]